Saylor’s Strategy Pivot: High-Yield Preferred Stock Now Funding Bitcoin Buys

Strategy (MSTR) is doubling down on its quest to transform into a high-yield Bitcoin treasury, financing its latest $168.4 million digital-asset acquisition through a novel mix of common and preferred equity. The company, led by Executive Chairman Michael Saylor, purchased 2,486 Bitcoin between Feb. 9 and Feb. 16, notably funding nearly half of the deal via at-the-market sales of its "Stretch" preferred shares. This tactical shift toward perpetual preferred stock underscores a pivot away from pure common equity dilution as Strategy grapples with a steep contraction in its share price premium and a volatile crypto market that has left the firm facing billions in mark-to-market losses. The heavier reliance on "Stretch" preferred stock (STRC), which offers a variable 11.25% dividend, is a clear attempt by CEO Phong Le to insulate common shareholders from the visceral swings of the Bitcoin market. By offering what effectively functions as a junk-bond yield, Strategy is courting a new class of income-seeking investors willing to trade price appreciation for steady monthly payouts. The company now oversees a complex capital stack featuring nearly $8.5 billion in preferred shares, an amount that now exceeds its outstanding convertible debt, as it attempts to maintain its "perpetual bitcoin-buying machine" even as its core software business is dwarfed by its massive 717,131 BTC reserve. Market Overview:

• Strategy shares (MSTR) have tumbled nearly 15% this year, tracking a 50% slide in Bitcoin from its peak.
• The company reported a staggering $12.4 billion net loss for the fourth quarter amid crypto fragility.
• Bitcoin traded near $67,000 on Tuesday, significantly below the firm’s $76,027 average purchase price.

Key Points:

• Latest purchase of 2,486 BTC was funded 46% by "Stretch" preferred shares and 54% by common stock.
• The "Stretch" dividend rate was recently hiked to 11.25% to support shares near their $100 par value.
• Strategy currently holds over 3.4% of the total Bitcoin supply, worth approximately $48.8 billion.

Looking Ahead:

• Management plans to lean more heavily on preferred issuance to reduce common stock volatility in 2026.
• A $2.25 billion cash reserve has been established to provide over two years of preferred dividend coverage.
• Investor focus remains on the "42/42" plan, targeting $84 billion in total capital raises over three years.

Bull Case:

• MicroStrategy’s continued Bitcoin accumulation, now over 3.4% of total supply and worth nearly $49 billion, reinforces its position as the premier listed BTC proxy for institutional investors seeking levered exposure to the asset.
• Shifting funding from pure common-stock issuance toward perpetual preferreds helps protect existing common shareholders from further dilution while still financing incremental BTC purchases.
• The 11.25% variable dividend on “Stretch” preferreds can attract a new base of income-focused, credit-oriented investors who value steady cash flows more than price appreciation, broadening the company’s investor mix.
• A $2.25 billion cash reserve earmarked for more than two years of preferred-dividend coverage provides runway and reduces near-term liquidity risk, buying time for a potential recovery in Bitcoin prices.
• If Bitcoin eventually trades well above the firm’s ~$76,000 average purchase price, the combination of a massive BTC hoard and long-dated, fixed-cost capital could generate outsized equity upside relative to spot BTC.

Bear Case:

• MicroStrategy is deeply underwater on its BTC position, with Bitcoin trading well below its average cost and contributing to a $12.4 billion quarterly net loss and roughly $5.7 billion in unrealized losses, which remain a major overhang.
• The capital stack has become highly complex and heavy: roughly $8.5 billion in preferred equity now exceeds convertible debt, and the effective “junk-bond” yield on Stretch shares materially raises the company’s long-term funding cost.
• Paying 11.25% on perpetual preferreds to fund a volatile, non-yielding asset exposes the firm to negative carry if Bitcoin’s price stalls or falls further, potentially eroding equity value over time.
• The business intelligence software segment is now dwarfed by the BTC treasury, leaving shareholders largely dependent on a single, highly volatile macro asset rather than a diversified operating business.
• As the premium of the common stock to underlying NAV compresses or turns into a discount, the traditional “issue equity above NAV to buy more BTC” flywheel breaks down, limiting MicroStrategy’s ability to grow its holdings without destroying shareholder value.
• If crypto markets face a prolonged downturn or capital conditions tighten further, MicroStrategy’s aggressive financial engineering could hit its practical limits, forcing painful balance-sheet adjustments just as its liabilities remain long-dated and expensive.

The transition from a business intelligence firm to a Bitcoin-proxy holding company has reached a critical juncture as the "premium to NAV" model that fueled Strategy’s meteoric rise begins to stall. With the company's market capitalization now occasionally dipping below the value of its underlying Bitcoin holdings, the ability to issue new shares without destroying shareholder value has become increasingly strained. By leaning into perpetual preferred equity, Saylor is betting that he can maintain accumulation momentum by shifting risk toward credit-minded investors, even as the broader crypto market remains mired in a post-liquidation hangover. Ultimately, Strategy’s aggressive financial engineering reflects the high stakes of a "Bitcoin-only" treasury policy in a tightening capital environment. While analysts at Bernstein note that the firm’s long-dated liabilities and ample cash reserves provide a buffer against immediate debt maturities, the massive $5.7 billion in unrealized losses remains a significant overhang. Whether the "Stretch" preferred shares can successfully decouple the company’s funding needs from the erratic movements of its common stock will determine if Strategy can survive a prolonged crypto winter or if its levered bet is reaching its mathematical limit.

This article contains syndicated content. We have not reviewed, approved, or endorsed the content, and may receive compensation for placement of the content on this site. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.